Copyright © 2004 jsd
As always, electrons flowing in is the same as positive current flowing out, and vice versa.
That’s essentially all there is to it.
There is one execrable exception, as discussed below.
You should never apply the terms anode or cathode to a Zener diode, because the potential for confusion is too great. Instead you should refer to the P-doped side and the N-doped side, and you should insist that others do the same.
Note that reversing the labeling convention for Zener diode arrays would not solve the problem in any fundamental sense, because there are perfectly reasonable circuits in which – part of the time – a Zener diode is forward biased, so that it conducts just like any other diode. This is the same situation we encounter in connection with rechargeable batteries: if you attach permanent anode/cathode labels to the structure, you will be wrong at least part of the time.
Let us make a brief exception to the black-box viewpoint, and consider what happens inside an electrochemical cell. Inside the cell, cations (positively charged species) moving toward the cathode make a positive contribution to the conventional current inside the cell, as shown in figure 2. Similarly, anions (negatively charged species) moving toward the anode make a positive contribution to the conventional current inside the cell. No anions are shown in the figure. The rule anions-to-anode, cations-to-cathode applies only inside the cell. This rule is required by the fact that current obeys a conservation law; current that flows into the cell at the anode must flow through the cell and then out the cathode. Outside the cell, current flows toward the anode; inside the cell, current flows away from the anode. (By the way, it is usually assumed that outside the cell, there are no mobile anions or cations, just electrons moving via the external circuit.)
When talking about ions, you need to remember that cations are positively charged. The mnemonic for cations is to view the ‘t’ as a plus sign: ca+ion. Meanwhile, the mnemonic for anions is something of an acronym: A Negative ION = ANION.
When remembering the cations-to-cathode rule, you need to remember that cations go to (not from) the cathode: ca+ions +o ca+hode. The corresponding anions-to-anode rule is equally valid, but you have to work harder to remember that the anions go to (not from) the anode.
I am astonished that some people take a concept that is simple and unimportant, make it needlessly complex, and pretend it is important.
When dealing with batteries, don’t think in terms of anode and cathode; think in terms of positive terminal and negative terminal.
When dealing with semiconductor diodes, don’t worry about anode and cathode; think in terms of P-doped side and N-doped side.
The general rule is: Anode means current into the black box and cathode means current out from the black box. Zener diodes give rise to an execrable exception that should be avoided like the plague.
There is abundant evidence that even people who call themselves experts cannot keep the anode/cathode terminology straight. In any practical situation, there is always a way to figure out how to hook things up without a deep understanding of anode versus cathode.
In almost all situations, it is better to avoid the terms anode and cathode. There are better ways to say what needs to be said. Constructive suggestion: it is better to talk about the current (rather than the electrode). It is better to talk about what the current is doing (rather than what the electrode “is”).
Copyright © 2004 jsd